Ninety minutes. That is how long Buckingham Palace, an institution that prizes silence above almost everything, took to answer the first excerpt from Earl Charles Spencer's Swan Song: Diana, My Sister. When the Palace stops saying nothing, you know something landed.

Buy Swan Song Here, Credit: Penguin

It's been about a week since the Daily Mail began rolling out the excerpts, and the book itself published on Sept. 22. I predicted it would be explosive. No psychic prize for me there, of course it was going to be. We knew it would be bad for King Charles, the man who betrayed Diana (by his own admission, in a 1994 documentary interview). But is the damage lasting, how has the rest of the family fared, and who has come out ahead?

The King's Hasty Reply

Before the book, King Charles had pulled a blinder. YouGov's July tracker had 68% of Britons saying he was doing a good job, the highest since he took the throne. Sympathy after his cancer diagnosis and affection for how he handled the Trump state visit had done him no harm. But has the past come home to haunt him, and does it dent his legacy?

Let's start with the most damaging claim. Spencer alleges that during a furious call about the funeral arrangements, Charles told him "we'll forget her soon enough", and Spencer says he relayed the words to friends and family at the time because they struck him as monstrous. He also says Charles sounded elated on the morning Diana died, as though he had won the lottery. In a later CBS interview, Spencer added that Charles once told him he was lucky to have inherited so young, days after Spencer's father died. Spencer floated the theory that Charles was elated because he was now free to marry Camilla, but when the BBC's Laura Kuenssberg pressed him, he conceded he could not be certain and was going on the tone of the call.

Buckingham Palace chose to reply, within 90 minutes. An aide told The Sunday Times a line had been crossed and that silence could not stand against such injustice. That first looked bold, but on reflection most people have noticed it was no denial, and Spencer himself says the Palace smudged its response.

Keep reading with a CI subscription to unlock the rest of this story, including whether King Charles's popularity actually took a hit, the credibility problem Charles Spencer didn't see coming, how the book accidentally became Prince Harry's best week in years, and the full winners-and-losers scoreboard.

Friends of the King say the heartless portrait doesn't ring true, though one who knows him well allows that divorce and grief can make people say things they regret. Meanwhile, The Sunday Times reports that some of the friends and family Spencer says he confided in at the time have come forward to back him.

Andrew Morton’s Biography, Credit: Michael O'Mara Books

But is the damage lasting? My read, and it is only that, is that opinions have barely moved. Those who loved Charles still do, and those who didn't have had their views confirmed. Many of these anecdotes have appeared in earlier books and articles, and this war has been on the record since Andrew Morton's book in 1992 and Panorama in 1995. A YouGov poll of 4,833 adults, published Thursday, asked about one claim: that Charles said Diana would soon be forgotten. 31% thought it probably or definitely true, 36% thought it probably or definitely not, and 33% didn't know. That is a slim edge for the King, with a third of the country undecided.

Celebrity Intelligence Verdict: The two quotable lines stick, and the Palace's decision to answer wasn't wise, but the rollout of friends and colleagues defending him was well executed. This wasn't great for the King, but I don't think it has hurt him in a lasting way, since the bombshells are new details of what we already knew.

Spencer Sings Solo

Charles Spencer is the only player who picked this fight, and he picked the timing too. The Palace said fraternal grief can cloud reason and color memory. Spencer told the Mail on Sunday he had been "gaslit by the King", and told the BBC he was certain those were the exact words and that he had heard, no denial. I'm not sure the Earl cares about his popularity. But the gaslighting line did not warm him in the heartland of the UK, and he should have let the words in his book stand for themselves. (A side note: he has done too many interviews. Poor People magazine seems to have been last in line.)

He has won financially, though the numbers are smaller than the headlines. Publishing sources told The Sun the advance was between £750,000 and £1 million, with a possible £5 million to £10 million if the book takes off in the US. For scale, The Sunday Times reports he recently sold 300 acres of farmland for £60 million. He has been branded a hypocrite, because in a 1998 interview he vowed never to profit from Diana's death, and the King's allies say he once lectured the media for hounding his sister and is now trading in her privacy. The Tory leader, Kemi Badenoch, has said she is always on the King's side.

But I believe motive should be separated from truth, and on the Charles material, nobody has produced evidence against his central allegations. That's harder to do about a private phone call. It's a different story with Piers Morgan. The book claimed Morgan was behind a 1993 leak of gym photos of Diana, when he was two years away from even joining that paper. Spencer has now apologized, admitting the assumption was "incorrect," and Penguin will correct digital and future print editions, though Spencer won't recall the first editions already in shops. That's not nothing: it's the first confirmed factual error in the book, by the author's own admission. But Morgan isn't backing down. His lawyers, Shillings, sent a legal letter to Spencer and Penguin on publication day demanding the first editions be pulled, and he says he's "spitting blood." He's pressing ahead with legal action, and he's framed the apology as proof of a bigger problem, asking publicly what else in the book can be trusted. That's not a question Spencer can apologize his way out of. Nor is the gym photo the only dispute. Spencer stands by his account of the phone call in which he withdrew Morgan's invitation to Diana's funeral, and says Morgan "snarled." Morgan calls that "an absolute lie."

Has it hurt his relationships with William and Harry? Harry doesn't seem affected. William is another story: the Daily Mail's Rebecca English reports he was deeply disappointed, though she had no official confirmation, and The Sunday Times says insiders describe fury that spans generations. William is not close to Spencer, and Kensington Palace has not commented. There is a poignant wrinkle, too. William has to pass through Spencer's Althorp estate to visit his mother's resting place.

Celebrity Intelligence Verdict: He has won financially, lost ground in the UK's affections, and now has a confirmed error on the record, one he's admitted to himself. He’s possibly a credible narrator on Charles but Piers Morgan has chipped away at that too even though it’s unprovable. 

William Keeps Calm and Carries On

Was anything negative said about William in the book? No. Spencer describes a composed 15-year-old, the image of his mother, whose composure made him Spencer's secondary concern that morning. That is a small sting, but not an attack.

William has said nothing, and the Windsor motto of never complaining and never explaining has been executed to perfection this past week. While Harry was making headlines in London, William announced the Earthshot finalists and played shinty with Catherine on the Isle of Bute in the pouring rain. HELLO!'s Emily Nash calls him arguably the man in the most difficult situation, since he has to keep the show on the road while the whole palace machinery is accused. Royal historian Alex Larman suggests William may see the timing as damaging to an institution he hopes to reform. He has proved himself steadfast, with a CEO's poker face: no emotion, just the job at hand.

Celebrity Intelligence Verdict: William is an unproven winner. Silence protects the heir, but a book that reaches into his family's past leaves his future job as monarch exposed, however calm he looks.

Harry, Home Again

The book has been good for Harry. The timing was luck. What he's done with it wasn't.

Start with the distraction. While the press pack has been consumed by Spencer's claims about Charles, Harry has quietly gone about becoming part of the furniture again. He's done two or three engagements since arriving back, at the Invictus Spirit Awards, launching the INSPIRE education program in Birmingham, and at WellChild. That's a run of appearances that show him at his best: the charity work he's known for, done well, in public, with almost none of the usual press friction, because the press has somewhere else to look.

Then there's the humanizing. His interview with HELLO! at the Invictus event mixed the serious with the ordinary. He talked about the kids being settled in school, about being back among old friends, threw in a joke about "sharing" his highlights of the past fortnight. That's the version of Harry the UK used to like: warm, self-deprecating, a bit cheeky, not a headline about a lawsuit or a rift.

Hello! magazine gave Harry a welcome home red velvet cake and the cozy interview helped warm him to the British public. Credit: Hello Instagram

And here's the twist: even the book's own revelations work in his favor. Spencer writes that on the funeral morning, Harry looked "tiny, and slight, and bereft," and that in the aftermath he was allowed to "spin out of control" without the care he needed. None of that is an attack on Harry. It's a reminder of what he actually went through: a 12-year-old walking behind his mother's coffin, grieving without support. Reading it now doesn't make people think less of Harry. It reminds them why they felt for him in the first place.

Put it together and the book has done Harry a favor twice over: once by taking the press's attention off him, and once by refreshing the public's sympathy for the boy at the center of the story it's telling.

The wrinkle is that Harry and his family stayed with Spencer at Althorp this summer, so this isn't a stranger's book. A source I trust tells me William and Harry knew the book was coming but not what was in it, which fits reporting in the Telegraph and The Sunday Times that Spencer gave his nephews no hint of the contents. Spencer has also spoken up for him directly, telling the BBC that the criticism of Harry and Meghan has echoes of what happened to Diana, which helps Harry's case that the press treats him unfairly.

Celebrity Intelligence Verdict: Harry wins the week but not the war. He inches William out as this week's big winner, but here is the catch for the Sussexes. Book cycles fade, and in my estimate this one has a fortnight left in it.  

The Supporting Cast

On Queen Elizabeth, Spencer says she offered on the day of the funeral to restore Diana's HRH title, and he turned it down as a "consolation prize." That reads less as conciliatory than as too late. He also alleges a senior aide told him the boys were to walk in the procession, and that his father once had a romantic connection with the young Princess Elizabeth, ended by Lord Mountbatten. He paints Prince Philip more kindly, with his usual gruffness replaced by a calm and quiet kindness.

Celebrity Intelligence Verdict: This detail, despite the Earl's characterization, warms the Queen even further with the British public.

Queen Camilla says nothing and does not have to. Spencer writes that Diana found a bracelet Charles bought for her. The strain of that period runs through the book's early chapters, including a claim that Charles made a remark about Diana's weight not long after their engagement, one Spencer says wounded her deeply. She is accused of nothing new, but she is the unspoken subtext of the whole book. YouGov's July tracker had her split, with 43% positive and 44% unfavorable. She broke her silence only once, telling her own book festival audience at Chatsworth to come "together," which is as close to a comment as she's going to make.

Celebrity Intelligence Verdict: Popularity and legacy surprisingly unmoved. A word for unity is the closest she'll come to a response, and it's probably the smartest one available to her.

The Real Loser: The Institution Itself

Here's the thing none of the individual scorecards capture. Charles survives this. Spencer profits from it. Harry gets a quiet fortnight out of it. But step back, and what actually happened this week is that the family that's supposed to represent continuity and dignity spent seven days as a soap opera, an earl accusing a king of gaslighting him, a broadcaster threatening to sue over gym photos, a Palace statement that reads like a subtweet.

None of it is new information, and none of it moves anyone's fixed opinion of Charles. But that's exactly the point. This isn't the first family drama to play out in public, and it won't be the last. Every round of it, whether it's a memoir, a Netflix documentary, or a lawsuit over a leotard photo, chips away a little more at the idea that the monarchy is above the noise. It's an accumulation problem, not a single-week one, but this is another entry on the ledger.

Ipsos's June survey has support for keeping the monarchy at 55%, the lowest since its series began in 1993, and just 33% among 18 to 34s, even as Charles himself remains personally popular. That's the gap worth watching: the man can be liked while the institution loses ground, and a week like this one, played out in real time on social media and reduced to "who won" scoreboards like mine, is exactly the kind of content that makes a younger generation roll its eyes at the whole enterprise rather than feel any reverence for it.

Celebrity Intelligence Verdict: Everyone in this story can point to a win. The institution can't. It just looks smaller.

I hope your week was calmer the royal family’s and that you have an amazing weekend, I will be trying to take a deep breath and escape the royal drama for a few moments!

Reply

Avatar

or to participate